[whatwg] Re: Autodiscovery
fantasai.lists at inkedblade.net
Tue May 3 22:52:01 PDT 2005
Phil Ringnalda wrote:
> Arve Bersvendsen wrote:
>> On Tue, 03 May 2005 18:52:59 +0200, Tim Bray <Tim.Bray at Sun.COM> wrote:
>> 1) Change the attribute value for the rel from "alternate" to "feed",
> Don't forget, since you would be doing that primarily for people who
> think too much, that you'll also need to include a profile  URI and
> make a guess at what dereferencing that URI ought to return, and
> probably take a stab at explaining how to deal with multiple profiles,
> since the HTML spec punted on that.
This would not be necessary if 'feed' were added to the HTML standard
> Popularizing "feed" would have one benefit outside Atom's scope, though:
> there's currently no useful way for an RSS 1.0 feed to do autodiscovery
> with type="application/rdf+xml" since it could be any alternate RDF, not
> just RSS: if Atom breaks the ice with "feed" then RSS 1.0 wins.
'feed' is not really defining a /relation/, it's defining a sort of
meta-content-type... But I would much prefer that to forcing 'alternate'
on non-'alternate' links.
(Copying to WHATWG mailing list: http://www.whatwg.org/ )
More information about the whatwg