[whatwg] The problems with namespaces in text/html (Was: MathML-in-HTML5)
lachlan.hunt at lachy.id.au
Sun Nov 5 06:01:59 PST 2006
Elliotte Harold wrote:
> Lachlan Hunt wrote:
>> Why is the specific syntax so important?
> The specific syntax is important because there's a huge, useful
> toolchain for processing XML and there's essentially zilch for
> processing this strange HTML 5 thing.
In the real world, you cannot expect to be be able to process content
served as text/html using XML tools. That's like trying to compile Java
with a C++ compiler. Despite the similarities in syntax, they are
different languages that require different parsers.
> Why not ditch the HTML 5 layer completely and simply allow the XML tools
> direct access?
Because we have to remain compatible with the web, where there are an
infinite number of existing documents that browsers must be able to
> Who, exactly is this HTML serialization supposed to help?
Anyone for whom interoperability in processing real world content is
important. This includes, among others:
* Browser vendors that have to deal with real world content.
* CMS, editor, and other tool vendors that have to accept HTML input
* Authors that have to develop for the real world.
* Users who like to surf the web in any browser they choose.
More information about the whatwg