[whatwg] video tag: pixel aspect ratio
philipj at opera.com
Mon Dec 1 16:19:18 PST 2008
On Mon, 2008-12-01 at 23:07 +0100, Lachlan Hunt wrote:
> > Given the number of people who watch 4:3 video stretched to a 16:9
> > display without even noticing/caring that the aspect ratio is wrong,
> While I'm aware that there are such people, largely because they don't
> know how to configure their TV's properly or because their TV's are
> broken by design, there are many others who do notice the difference
> (including myself). From my experience, stretching a 4:3 picture to
> fill a 16:9 screen is enough to make people on the screen look weird and
> out of proportion. It's less noticeable with cartoons, but in general,
> it's very noticeable and annoying. We should inflict such annoyances
> upon end users if it avoidable; at least not by default.
The point wasn't that it is OK for UA:s to distort video because there
are people who don't notice, but that some people do/will encode video
with the wrong aspect ratio without noticing/caring. The general
consensus seems to be that this isn't worth the effort fixing.
But in any event, if a CSS solution is in fact possible that would be
much better than any video-specific solution. I don't think CSS
transforms can do it though, unless someone can give an example?
More information about the whatwg