[whatwg] Is there any reason for the continued existence of enctype attribute at the form element
bzbarsky at MIT.EDU
Sun Oct 11 07:00:09 PDT 2009
On 10/11/09 6:59 AM, Mark Kaplun wrote:
> I think that in practice no one is writing his own mime handling
> routines to handle the data in a post message, and people just use a
> framework which handles it for them.
While this may be true (and I'm not sure it's as true as one would like)
some of these "frameworks" are more or less capable than others. Some
expect the data in a _very_ particular format (such that changing the
order of elements in the submitted data, for example breaks them); I
would not expect them to switch easily between different enctypes.
> I don't know enough about other server languages but I would assume that
> handling the post mime type automagically is one of the basic candies
> that every modern server language provides.
A surprising amount of form POST processing seems to happen in an exe on
the server, not in any sort of modern scripting language. At least
based on the bugs we've gotten filed whenever we change anything about it.
More information about the whatwg