[whatwg] Appcache feedback (various threads)
pmuellr at muellerware.org
Fri Aug 13 06:18:13 PDT 2010
On 8/12/10 6:29 PM, Ian Hickson wrote:
> On Wed, 19 May 2010, Patrick Mueller wrote:
>> I've been playing with application cache for a while now, and found the
>> diagnostic information available to be sorely lacking.
>> For example, to diagnose user-land errors that occur when using
>> appcache, this is the only practical tool I have at my disposal:
>> tail -f /var/log/apache2/access_log /var/log/apache2/error_log
>> I'd like to be able to get the following information:
>> - during "progress" events, as identified in step 17 of the application
>> cache download process steps in 6.6.4 "Downloading or updating an
>> application cache"), I'd like to have the URL of the resource that
>> is about to be downloaded. The "progress" event from step 18 (
>> indicating all resources have been downloaded) doesn't need this.
> What do you need this for?
See the first sentence: diagnostic information.
>> - for all error conditions, some indication of WHAT error occurred.
>> Presumably an error code. If the error involved a particular resource,
>> I'd like the URL of the resource as well.
>> I'm not sure what the best mechanisms might be to provide this info:
>> - extend the events used to add this information
>> - provide this information in the ApplicationCache interface -
>> lastErrorCode, lastResourceDownloaded, etc
>> - define a new object as the target for these events (currently
>> undefined,or at least not clear to me), and add that info to the target
>> - something else
> Could you describe how you would use this information? What would you do
> differently based on this information?
again: diagnostic information.
Of course, there's not much I can "do" differently, based on this
information, since there's little I can "do" with app-cache to begin
with, being largely declarative.
I understand the typical response here is: use a debugger. That's fine,
and that's right, for most of my purposes, but means I'm relying on a
tool to get information, that a normal application might not be able to
As an example, an application might collect a log of errors and post
them back to a server for diagnostic purposes later. Not possible if
the only way to get app-cache diagnostics is with a "web debugger".
There's a good argument for not providing this information, I suppose:
you can't get it for non-app-cache scenarios, why should you get it for
app-cache scenarios? (I'm assuming here that you can't get
HTTP-transport level information from anything but XHR, WebSocket, etc
sort of APIs - you don't get that sort of information about a .css file
you referenced in your .html file, for instance).
Additionally, are there security issues that I'm not aware of (haven't
though enough about)?
None-the-less, we do have these nice events coming in, there's plenty of
room for more information in them, and they would serve a useful purpose
since app-cache has proven, to me, to be an occasionally challenging
corner of the room to play in.
Patrick Mueller - http://muellerware.org
More information about the whatwg