[whatwg] Comparison of XForms-Tiny and WF2

Matthew Raymond mattraymond at earthlink.net
Thu Jan 25 17:59:40 PST 2007


Klotz, Leigh wrote:
>>   Explain to me why Web Forms 2.0 shouldn't be "incorporating more of
>> the great ideas" in XForms-Tiny rather than the other way around. Why is
>> your approach to cannibalize an existing W3C working draft to enrich a
>> draft you haven't even finished yet? What, in your opinion, makes WF2
>> unsalvageable?
>
> Or what makes you want to cannibalize an existing W3C Recommendation
> which predates the formation of WHAT-WG?

   Are you trying to justify hypercannibalization?!? Or are you just
trying to cover up the fact that XForms and WF2 don't occupy the same
niche, but XForms-Tiny and WF2 do?



More information about the whatwg mailing list